Friday, November 1, 2019


Module 9: 


Summarizing and Discussing Phase 2 Topics and Interests








This week’s post is a reflection of the key learnings and thoughts from the inquiry phase of our course, LIBE 477, which focused on developing and promoting reading cultures, professional development, personal learning networks, and how libraries in developing nations are supported by various organizations and technologies. While each week's inquiry was centred around a different and distinct topic for research and reflection, common themes appeared while new learning and ideas emerged. Reading blogs from classmates was an excellent source of information and new learnings. It's fascinating to see how ideas around the same inquiry topic can yield such different research avenues, resources and perspectives. I found this process very valuable. 


 What am I going to take with me? From what I’ve found and what I’ve learned from others


It’s amazing how one week of inquiry can change my perspectives and add to my learning. Our last topic was not initially what I thought I’d focus on as a major takeaway, but it really opened up my eyes to how critical libraries are in terms of people around the world being able to access information. I’d previously realized the importance that libraries play in developing literacy for students, and in education in general, but I had not really given thought to how it bridges social and economic gaps, and that limited access to libraries can mean a 
social disadvantage for a segment of the population. I guess in general terms, I was looking at it through a very personal and narrow lens, and have now been able to expand my thinking. Specific quotes such as how libraries "can be the difference between users simply accessing information or being able to use it" have resonated with me. (Heath, 2019) Another quote from classmate Kristi Nichol's post, a “lack of internet has come to mean lack of opportunity" has also stuck with me throughout the week.  There were many good blog posts about the importance of libraries and mobile devices that really show the importance that both play in society-across many social, economic and educational classes. The close link that exists between libraries and literacy around the world is important and one that I hadn’t considered as much before last week's research. 



Other Key Takeaways:

  • Promoting a positive reading culture and fostering a love of reading has been a primary goal and is an area of particular interest for me. I often try to find new and engaging ways to draw more students into the library to explore books, and I emphasize that reading can and should be fun. I thoroughly enjoyed researching and reading about all of the ways we can foster a love of reading. There are many great ideas that I can now add and incorporate into my existing practice. Additionally, I noted that many classmates added Dr. Stephen Krashen's ideas and videos about the importance of reading for pleasure and the role libraries play in this. I've bookmarked the video by Dr.Krashen that Lara Walters added, so that I can reference it later.  
          Image citation
  • While I feel that I've always been fairly dedicated to professional development, and have tried to vary my learning opportunities, I was grateful that the inquiry focus on professional development prompted me to dig even deeper. As a result I've now established connections with amazing teachers throughout the province who are eager and willing to mentor and share learning around ADST, which is a topic that I need more exposure to and experience with. One of the key points for me is the importance of finding and maintaining a passion to explore a new topic through hands on learning experiences. Another was balance. I want to continue learning about new, engaging technologies and lessons but after this learning phase, I've realized the value of learning one thing well as opposed to taking on too much at once. 
  • Establishing better Personal Learning Networks (PLNs) was good for me to investigate further. I knew this was important, but I'd admittedly sometimes put it on the back-burner. After researching and reading blogs from classmates, I know I need to make sure I continue to prioritize this. Stepping out of my comfort zones and engaging more through social media is a personal goal, as well as speaking more and sharing with district learning groups. As Kelli McLeod suggested a “digital teaching friend” is a great place to start. Maintaining my commitment to my PLN will be a focus and this means not putting off a meeting, and recognizing the value it can have for my teaching practice and working relationships. Sharing personally with other TLs and mentors is one of my best motivators, and it helps me stay grounded and focus my learning. I've learned to value this even more.
  • I borrowed the Teacher Librarian: Your Inquiry Superhero from Jennifer Losell, as it's an amazing reminder. #InquiryMindset is a hashtag that I am exploring on a deeper level with a colleague, and I printed this as a visual motivator. I connect it with #GrowthMindset, which this course is teaching me a lot about. 


        


       
              
  • Developing reading skills on e-readers versus traditional print is another topic I've been thinking about since last week. Our classmate, Christopher Lister, brought this question to my attention and it has led me to do some further research on the topic. I am thinking of it in terms of my role as a TL around digital literacies, as well as my role as a reading teacher. I now feel compelled to explore more and am excited to explore this topic further.


A Little Bit More Sharing... 


Even though the debate about using mobile devices was not a direct inquiry assignment, I came across research surrounding this topic and found it quite relevant. It's a hot topic right now as debates are swirling and mobile device bans are happening.

A study (2017) from Edutopia that intrigued me, outlines the negative impact of mobile devices in classrooms, primarily citing that the mere presence of such devices is a powerful distraction. Reasoning from this study states that devices are occupying students' mental space and triggering a neuro-system called "automatic attention," which unconsciously monitors the environment for signs of critical importance. It suggests that this is happening even when devices are not physically in the hands of students. This is an interesting idea, and certainly an argument worth investigating for those interested in the debate. The video below explains this idea further. 




Additionally, articles "Banning Mobile Phones in Schools: Beneficial or Risky? Here's What the Evidence Says,"  and "Cell Phones in the Classroom: Learning Tool or Distraction," explain why a state in Australia and the Ontario Ministry of Education have effectively banned mobile devices in classrooms.

Both articles list plausible reasons for and against the use of devices. They also indicate that more countries and states may be following suit. In both articles devices were permitted according to school discretion, if for example they were used for "educational purposes, medical reasons, or as a support for a student with special needs." 

Furthermore, both show that with proper management devices can be excellent tools for learning. A curious debate that I will continue to follow, especially as I encourage the use of more digital technologies.

Concerns With Devices
Positive Contributions of Devices
  • Cyberbullying
  • Student distraction
  • Student struggles with disobedience due to misuse of devices
  • Cheating
  • Disconnection from face-face connections

  • Using educational learning apps 
  • Incorporating digital platforms into lessons
  • Supplementing lessons with digital materials
  • Providing easy access to more information





Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

7 Comments:

At November 3, 2019 at 5:07 PM , Blogger Jen Losell said...

Hi Amy,
Firstly, I'd like to mention how cool it is that you have many references to the other member of our small group and what you have taken away from reading everyone else's blog over the last month. A great example of a PLN at work!

I think mobile devices will continue to be a contentious topic amongst educators. This really is uncharted territory as we did not grow up with the same access and experience. On the one hand we are so lucky to have more information than we'll ever need right at our fingertips, and the schools don't even need to purchase devices because most teens have their own. On the other, it's a whole generation that doesn't know life without a device. I do worry about the future generation's ability to connect with each other face to face, especially as many of them witness their parents constantly staring into the blue light of a mobile screen. Not to mention the other concerns you listed including distraction and cheating. This is something I think about often and I'm continually grateful that I teach primary students where I don't yet have to deal with the issues directly in the classroom (though I do see side-effects of many hours spent in front of a screen at home).

 
At November 4, 2019 at 6:14 AM , Blogger Aaron Mueller said...

Well done reflection post that tours us through your learning, new awareness, perspectives, key takeaways and important reminders. I especially appreciated your discussions of what you gained from each topic, as well as highlights from your small group and what they explored that resonated with you. Important points and discussions about mobile devices and their impacts on our students that demonstrates your in depth commitment to your ongoing inquiry on personalized topics!

 
At November 4, 2019 at 3:34 PM , Blogger Marie said...

Awesome post! I also loved that you connected to the blogs from the rest of our little community this term (thanks for the shout out!). Will you keep your blog going, now that the course is ending?

Thanks for the resources about the debate surrounding mobile devices in the classroom - it is such a tricky thing. We use these mobile devices all the time as adults in the world (banking, shopping, sending gifts, even taking courses!), so it's authentic to the future... but there does need to be a balance and attention paid to the neural development and social development that is happeneing. I have noticed that I have to explicately remind my students to look me in the eye when we are having a conversation, as so many of them seem to have difficulty with this. I don't know if it's due to excessive device use, something else, but it seems to correlate with the amount of technology that a child uses... I'll be following this debate as well as I try to balance it in my own life and my students' lives.
-Kelli

 
At November 4, 2019 at 7:45 PM , Blogger AmyS said...

Thanks Jen:)
The whole experience of reading a group of blogs is a great way to learn new things and find some connections with classmates.

I agree that the mobile devices debate is likely to continue. I'm quite intrigued by it and will continue to follow it. It's quite something that we in the developed world are banning technology that developing nations need more of. It really shows a disparity on a few levels.

 
At November 4, 2019 at 7:55 PM , Blogger AmyS said...

Hi Kelly,

Thanks, I enjoy reading everyone's blogs every week and really get a lot out of everyone's ideas. I'm hoping to keep the blog, although I'll have to think about how I can best go about doing that...I notice that you have another course on yours that I'm thinking of taking.
It seems like a good way to organize ideas and resources...

Technology has no doubted altered a lot for our children-everything from habits to attention to the wiring of the brain. It evens seems to affect fine motor skills. The research goes on and on. I guess we all need to work together to find balance and use technology in the best ways possible. It seems to me that this will take a lot more brainstorming and careful consideration, in the educational world and at home!

 
At November 7, 2019 at 3:29 PM , Blogger Kristi Nichol said...

Hi Amy

I felt the same way about the developing nations inquiry too! I learned so much about how libraries in developing nations are using technology to help with the local economy and build community - it goes so far beyond improving literacy. It made me reflect on how literacy affects every aspect of our lives.

Your research about mobile devices is interesting and I like how you summed it up visually with the table. I’m interested in exploring how we can take advantage of those benefits and reduce the distraction. I know some teachers use calculator holders near the door of the classroom for cell phones when they are not in use. I wonder whether cell phones are as much of a distraction if they are in one particular area of the room (like a class holder), but out of reach of the student?

 
At November 7, 2019 at 8:29 PM , Blogger AmyS said...

Hi Kristi,

I think that mobile devices in classrooms will be something we continue to debate. It seems to be quite an issue, with points to be made on both side. The most interesting piece of research I found was the video stating that cell phones are a distraction just being in the room. That being said, I haven't researched those sources, or that point beyond this post. It's a topic I think we all need to be aware of though, and watch as it plays out in different educational settings. There must be successful management methods that can be implemented.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home